You are hereLiebherr Group: Products & Services for Other countries
The town of Maniago, Italy, is principally known for two things: Knives and cutting tools. The whetstones of cutlers at the Còlvera stream, at the foot of the Carnic Alps, have been operated with hydropower since the 15th century – the start of a big handcraft tradition from which an industrial center developed. Since 1960 SIAP has been manufacturing gears, and since 1988 as part of the international Carraro Group. Gear boxes, axles, and contract manufacturing are the businesses conducted by the Italians.
“We are always growing”, explains COO Paolo De Col. In recent years, the premises underwent constant expansion. “We have to add a new hall practically every year.” This of course also means a continuous expansion of the fleet, which now includes over 200 machines - around 30 of which are from Liebherr. The most recent acquisitions were a LCS 500 generating grinding machine, a LC 300 gear hobbing machine, and the LK 500 gear skiving machine - the first of its kind in a production environment.
Partnership with a long history
“We have a long history with Liebherr. Firstly, two Liebherr companies are our customers, the connection to the group has therefore existed for a very long time. Secondly, we opened a plant in India in 2003/2004, which we equipped with around 25 Liebherr machines” states Paolo De Col. “The parts were manufactured in Germany and assembled in India. Liebherr Machine Tools India was set up in Bangalore at the same time as our subsidiary. We believe in Liebherr India and Carraro, who was confident of the excellent quality of the machines in our production, released an order of 25 machines, thereby opening up the Indian market.”
In addition, when it comes to gear skiving, SIAP demonstrated its huge confidence in the Kempten-based technologies. The company’s first manufacturing gear skiving machine is in Maniago. “For us, skiving is a new and very interesting topic. Together with Liebherr, we have the opportunity to jointly develop a new machine with a new process. Liebherr is familiar with all challenges of mass production – we have access to the developers and can bring about improvements, both to the machine, and to the process and tools.” The Liebherr skiving3 (machine, tool, and technology) approach is also very effective in the collaboration with SIAP.
Focus on costs and quality
Luca Cadelli, sales manager of SIAP, responds to the question about why SIAP is mainly introducing the new technology: “The market requires this machining method. Gear skiving promises better quality while reducing costs. This combination is irresistible for our customers, because everyone pays attention to costs and quality.” Cadelli and De Col expect that a successful introduction of the skiving³ process will be critical for gaining a competitive edge in the medium term.
At SIAP the LK 500 produces, e.g. various internal gearings - a classic application for gear skiving, as here only the considerably slower gear shaping technology can be used. “We are extremely satisfied with the production speed”, reports the COO. “The machine works roughly five times faster than our shaping machines. If we want to expand our production, we compare the procurement of a skiving machine to the purchase of three shaping machines in the latest generation.” Other costs are included in this comparison: number of operators, installation space, tool costs and set-up times. “A single machine has clear benefits of course.” Even without the gear skiving machine, SIAP currently has a daily production capacity of 3000 internal gears.
Skiving will partly replace the broaching process
SIAP uses five broaching machines for large quantities. As the broaches are very expensive for low volumes due to the high tool and sharpening costs, SIAP uses broaching for straight gears. The company expects a partial replacement of the process in the future with skiving. “In the future broaching will only be worthwhile for mass productions of part numbers with high volume. Especially for large toothed gears, the tool costs will decide whether we broach or skive”, predicts Paolo De Col. From a certain size the broaching tools become so expensive that the process is no longer worthwhile.
Another decisive benefit of skiving: The quality remains consistently excellent across the entire tool life. “The process is completely stable. Skiving thus satisfies four requirements: quality, cost benefit, consistency and reliability of the process.”
As SIAP not only produces toothed gears, but also complete gearboxes - for example for forklifts - the company has extensive process and quality competence. The latter is also reflected in the production equipment: Test engineers examine the products in labs for metallurgy, measurements, and purity. One project is “clean production”, the contamination-free production for preferably pure components.
“We are always open to innovative approaches and technologies”, highlights Paolo De Col. “We are therefore also happy to pursue the skiving³ path with Liebherr.“ A display of trust which Liebherr appreciates and led to a fruitful partnership. The machine should be fully integrated in production by the end of the year and manufactures the entire range of parts. Then SIAP will decide about more procurements - another LK 500 is also on the wish list.